September 1, 2007. Ann Arbor, Michigan. 109,218 fans. The largest crowd ever to watch a college football game at that point.
They came to watch their fifth-ranked Wolverines demolish Appalachian State, a Division I-AA school from Boone, North Carolina, population 17,000. Michigan was a 33-point favorite. The spread was so lopsided that most sportsbooks didn't even offer it.
Two hours and forty-seven minutes later, Appalachian State walked off the field as 34-32 winners. And betting on college football was never quite the same.
THE SETUP: WHY THIS GAME "COULDN'T" HAPPEN
Let's understand exactly how insane this was. Appalachian State wasn't even in the same division as Michigan. They played FCS football (then called Division I-AA). The Mountaineers' entire athletic budget was roughly what Michigan spent on just their football program's equipment.
Michigan brought in Appalachian State as a guaranteed win and an easy payday for a small school. The Wolverines paid the Mountaineers $400,000 to show up and lose. That's how these games worked. That's how they'd always worked.
No FCS team had ever beaten a top-5 team. The talent gap was supposed to be insurmountable. Michigan had more 5-star recruits on their roster than Appalachian State had total scholarship players.
💡 What Oddsmakers Thought
The 33-point spread was actually conservative. Many sportsbooks simply refused to post a line on this game because they couldn't find enough Appalachian State believers to take the other side. The implied moneyline for App State would've been somewhere around +10000 to +15000.
HOW IT ACTUALLY HAPPENED
Appalachian State came in with one advantage nobody was talking about: they'd won back-to-back FCS national championships. These were experienced players who knew how to win big games. They just happened to play against smaller schools.
Michigan Takes 28-17 Lead
The Wolverines score four touchdowns, and everything looks normal. Michigan fans relax. The spread seems safe.
App State Claws Back
The Mountaineers score 10 unanswered points. Suddenly it's 28-27. The Big House gets quiet.
App State Takes the Lead
Armanti Edwards runs for a touchdown. App State leads 34-32 with 5 minutes left. 109,000 people can't believe what they're watching.
Michigan's Last Chance
Michigan drives to the App State 20. A 37-yard field goal attempt would win the game...
THE BLOCK
Corey Lynch leaps and blocks the kick. App State recovers. The biggest upset in college football history is complete.
THE BETTING AFTERMATH
Here's what made this game legendary for bettors: almost nobody could actually bet on Appalachian State. Most books pulled the line entirely. The few that kept it had tiny limits.
But the ripple effects were enormous:
⚠️ The Parlay Carnage
Thousands of college football parlays had Michigan as a "lock" to cover 33 points. Almost nobody took the game as a standalone bet—it was parlay filler, guaranteed money. Every single one of those tickets died on the first Saturday of the season.
The game fundamentally changed how bettors and oddsmakers viewed FCS-vs-FBS matchups. Before App State-Michigan, lines of 30+ points were common. After? Books got much more conservative, and sharps started looking for value on heavy underdogs.
WHAT BETTORS CAN LEARN
This game should be required viewing for anyone who thinks any bet is "safe."
1. There Are No Locks
Michigan was as close to a lock as exists in sports betting. Massive talent advantage. Home field with 109,000 fans. Top-5 ranking. And they still lost. If this game can happen, any game can happen.
2. Parlay Padding Is Dangerous
The biggest losers weren't people who bet Michigan straight. They were bettors who threw Michigan -33 into multi-leg parlays to boost payouts on other games. When you add "sure things" to parlays, you're just adding ways to lose.
3. Championship Experience Matters
Appalachian State had won two straight national titles. That mental edge—knowing how to execute under pressure—matters more than most people realize. The Mountaineers weren't intimidated because they'd already played in bigger moments (for them).
4. Line Value Exists in Extreme Spreads
After this game, smart bettors started paying more attention to extreme spreads. A 33-point line means the favorite needs to win by almost five touchdowns. That's incredibly hard to do against anyone, let alone a championship-caliber team from a lower division.
🎯 The 1% Rule Connection
This is exactly why the 1% bankroll rule exists. If you'd put a huge percentage of your bankroll on Michigan that day, you'd have been devastated. Proper bankroll management means one historic upset can't wreck your whole season.
THE OHIO CONNECTION
For Ohio bettors, this game carries special significance. Michigan is Ohio State's biggest rival. Buckeye fans still talk about that Saturday in September with gleeful satisfaction.
But more importantly: Ohio State was scheduled to play Appalachian State the following year. Guess how that went? The Buckeyes won 43-0. Not every underdog story repeats.
That's the final lesson: every game is its own universe. What happened last week, last year, or in 2007 doesn't determine what happens next. That's what makes betting both exciting and humbling.
BY THE NUMBERS: APP STATE'S MIRACLE
THE BOTTOM LINE
Appalachian State 34, Michigan 32 remains the single most stunning upset in college football history. It's the game oddsmakers point to when someone asks "why don't you offer bigger spreads?" It's the game bettors should remember whenever they think they've found a guaranteed winner.
In sports betting, there are no guarantees. There are only probabilities. And sometimes—rarely, but sometimes—the improbable becomes reality.
🏈 Bet Smart on College Football
Looking for Ohio-legal sportsbooks to bet college football? Compare the best options for Buckeyes, Bearcats, and all your college football action in our Ohio sportsbook guide.